Skip to main content

Kiwi Home Building Schemes



Misleading or confusing news stories makes for tedious reading. I’ve found an article from Scoop titled KiwiBuy the only answer to the housing shortage which was written as a media release by the Salvation Army. This story falls mainly within the confusing bracket, however, it could be argued that when confused, readers can become lost and therefore miss the point completely.


The title makes a bold and somewhat biased statement; for starters there are 101 things that could make buying or building a home more affordable. So to say, ‘KiwiBuy is the only way’ is in my opinion somewhat short-sighted.  Maybe the title could say, “KiwiBuy scheme makes housing more affordable for low income bracket”.

The lead-in sentence states, “Growing homelessness, rent rises and struggles for private investors could be on the way without serious changes to the housing market, The Salvation Army says”. Does this mean private investors will be struggling less? Also, what is meant by housing market?

Firstly, the KiwiBuy initiative is designed as a rent to buy scheme and the ‘housing market’ is not what needs to change. What needs to change are government policies to reform laws around housing, immigration, land development, offshore investment, taxes and limitations to the numbers of homes one person or company could own.

The article goes on to mention its newspaper “Beyond Renting”. Then the article calls it a report which is somewhat confusing. From my perspective a newspaper and a report are different, so calling it what it is and sticking to it makes sense. Furthermore, the article mentions Kiwi Build and KiwiBuy which could lead to confusion. When introducing new concepts, explaining their meaning helps to create shared understanding for readers.
The next paragraph talks about ‘mum and dad; investors being the majority of investors in the housing market over the past 30 years. Instead of saying this, how about some actual statistics or even a graph giving an overall picture such as the one below provided by the Bank of New Zealand. Moreover, the term ‘mum and dad’ investors is somewhat ambiguous and possibly does not paint an accurate picture.

The next paragraph uses statistics and talks about yields falling in Auckland and possibly reaching the top of their cycle which sounds jargonistic. Jargon used in media releases is frowned upon as it can make the issue incomprehensible for readers. Also, at the end of a quote, Mr Johnson is credited without an introduction of who Mr Johnson is. It helps to aid credibility in an article by quoting someone who has direct knowledge or is a specialist on the topic being reported. Introducing them into the story supports the information giving it strength.
Further down in the article it is suggested that KiwiBuy and KiwiBuild are the two preferable methods of alleviating the housing crisis. In this instance the name Kiwi Build has become KiwiBuild and the story now contradicts its own headline. The final paragraph tries to address the issue of income and becomes ambiguous by introducing the concept of applying imagination and courage to the design of KiwiBuy so Kiwis in need can have a KiwiBuild house.
This last paragraph could be improved with factual data on income levels which correlate to the two housing schemes. And the final sentence could be restructured to say, both ‘KiwiBuy and KiwiBuild programmes require modification to ensure Kiwis are enabled to become home owners in their own country’. 

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Improved Outcomes for Fisheries in New Zealand

The Price of Fish In 1986, the New Zealand government introduced the QMS (Quota Management System) to regulate fishing in the country's coastal waters, which extend 200nm offshore and are divided into 10 Fisheries Management Areas (FMAs). Under the QMS, most fish species are subject to catch quotas within the Total Allowable Catch (TAC) and the Total Allowable Commercial Catch (TACC). The TACCs are reviewed annually by MPI (Ministry for Primary Industries), and based on fish populations, the appropriate TACCs are allocated to the FMAs. These TACCs are further divided into Individual Tradeable Quotas (ITQs), which are permanently given to commercial fisheries for free. This reflects the neoliberal policy decisions of that era, where public assets were divided among private interests as a means to generate wealth for the elite. Neoliberal economics assumes that wealth will trickle down from the wealthy to working-class citizens. However, this approach has led to fisheries feudalism, ...
Post a Comment
Read more

Commonwealth Connection

  Selena and Shamubeel Eaqub. Source: Idealog, (2015). Housing is a big issue for Kiwi’s and there's a commonwealth connection. Economist Shamubeel Eaqub (2015) makes comment on the situation in an report from Idealog titled "A culture of despair": How the NZ property dream became a nightmare . Eaqub said, “we’ve created a housing market impossible for young people to enter, a society one step away from a landed-class system, and a culture of despair”. The story goes on about what’s going wrong and how to fix things up. For example: more rights and responsibilities for renters, embracing technological property management systems, improving housing construction methods, effective land use and reformed governmental policy settings. Shamubeel and his wife Selena (pictured above) have written a book titled  Generation Rent: Rethinking New Zealand’s Priorities   which is mentioned within the report .   The report continues and focuses on ‘affordable...
Post a Comment
Read more

Is Noam Chomsky a raving anarchist, or does he just care for society?

Noam Chomsky. Source: DiEM25 (2020).   Is Noam Chomsky a raving anarchist, or does he just care for society? At the age of 91, Professor Noam Chomsky, author, linguist, historian, philosopher and political dissident currently lives with his second wife Valeria in Tucson Arizona. He grew up in Philadelphia during the Great Depression of the 1930s and has documented and written about the Spanish Civil War, the Cold War, the Cuban Missile Crisis, the Vietnam War, Cambodian dictatorship, the Watergate scandal, the Reagan and Thatcher era, the Iraq War, the global financial crisis of 2008 and recently, the reign of Donald Trump. Not only has Chomsky taught linguistics and social science for almost 50 years at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology , he’s written over 100 influential political books. According to Democracy Now , Chomsky’s recent books include  Global Discontents: Conversations on the Rising Threats to Democracy ,  Who Rules the World? ...
Post a Comment
Read more